Blue Guardian Reviews

Title: 5 Days of False Demands, Passed Liveness Test & Still Denied Verification - Account #550596 Review: I am extremely disappointed with Blue Guardian's support and compliance team. I have been trying to verify my Account # 550596 for the past 5 days. My account is 100% under my own name, and my CNIC matches all my details. I have already passed the 3D Liveness Verification, sent high-resolution CNIC photos, screen recordings, and a live ID-holding selfie as demanded. Despite completing all their demands, they falsely accused me of "Third-Party KYC" simply because SumSub's automated system could not read the Urdu script on my Pakistani National ID card. I have challenged this decision and offered a live video call verification with my original government-issued ID to prove my identity, but they refuse to resolve it. This is completely unfair and looks like a tactic to stall my payout. I demand upper management to intervene, perform a manual/live verification, and approve my account immediately.

(1) Competition Ranking & First Funded Account: After competing in multiple monthly competitions (breaching around 10 competition accounts during my learning phase), I secured 4th place in the June competition. As a result of this ranking, I was awarded a $50,000 Instant Standard Account. I actively traded this account for one month, successfully met all operational requirements, and received my first payout. Following the payout, this initial account was subsequently breached. (2) Second Funded Account Purchase & Second Payout Request: On August 16, I purchased a new $50,000 Instant Standard Account. After trading actively on this account for 10 days, I requested my second payout. (3)Clarification Regarding Communication: As English is not my native language, I kindly request that any previous communication or language limitations not be misunderstood or treated as a compliance issue. My focus remains entirely on delivering transparent trading results and adhering to firm rules. (4). Supporting Documentation: I am prepared to attach all relevant dashboard screenshots, including: First $50k Account trading history & payout proof Second $50k Account trading history & payout request status Official Competition Leaderboard Dashboard verifying my 4th-place ranking I respectfully request that the Risk Team conduct a manual audit of my dashboard, verify the history of both accounts, and process my pending request. Thank you for your time, consideration, and prompt support. Sincerely, Yamini Tandel Blue Guardian Trader

I requested a $388.48 payout with 0/2 breaches on my dashboard. Without placing any new trades, my status was suddenly changed to 0/1 breaches after requesting withdrawal, claiming a 1% floating loss occurred. The payout calculation is completely broken: Approved Profit: $388.48 After Split & Fees (80% - 2%): $304.56 Minus Tick Scalping (-$45.66): $258.90 Even with a 50% Soft Breach penalty: I should receive $129.45. However, only $69.70 was transferred to my wallet. This Guardian Shield breach was applied post-withdrawal, and the final payout math makes zero sense. I have emailed support and demand the Risk Team investigate and refund my withheld funds fairly.

​Overview & Summary of Loss ​Primary Account: $50,000 Instant Standard Account (#491687) ​Secondary Account: $10,000 1-Step Pro Account (#503550) ​Denied Funds: $1,040 USD (Primary Payout) + $430 USD (Secondary Account Profits) = $1,470 USD Total Seized ​Trader Stats: 5/5 profitable trading days, 19.66% consistency score (strictly under their 20% rule), and $0.00 total drawdown/loss. ​Do not be fooled by Blue Guardian’s slick marketing pushes, shiny new dashboard redesigns, or promotional discount offers. My experience proves that as soon as a trader meets all profit targets and requests a payout, Blue Guardian relies on flawed automated risk logs and improper system practices to deny payouts and lock traders out of their accounts. ​Key Faults & Manipulations Breakdown ​1. Scraping & Using Third-Party Competitor Broker Data (Goat Funded Ltd.) ​In the screenshot provided by Blue Guardian compliance manager (Taleb) to justify my manual breach for a "CID/Device Match," their internal table explicitly lists account #414320308. Account #414320308 is hosted on Goat Funded Ltd. (GoatFunded-Server2)—a completely separate, third-party proprietary firm. Blue Guardian is scraping and logging local MT5 client terminal data across separate brokers and using external platform activity as grounds to breach accounts on their platform. ​2. Contradictory & Mismatched System Evidence ​Even within their own system logs, their evidence crumbles under basic scrutiny: ​Mismatched Device Hashes: The CID hash associated with my $50k account (83237...ed) does not match the hash listed for the other accounts (b4753...3c). They cited an old starter account (#485300) with a "Last Trading Date" of July 3. That account was already breached and inactive over two months prior. An inactive, long-dead account cannot be used as proof of "simultaneous concurrent account sharing" on a late-July payout request. ​3. Collateral Damage & Hostage Taking of Active $10k Account ​After I challenged their compliance decision and pointed out their dashboard error, Blue Guardian took total administrative action: ​They completely blocked my master portal login ("Your account has been blocked"). ​This action forcibly severed my access to my live $10k Pro Account (#503550) sitting at +$430 USD in profit (with an upcoming payout date of August 3), which had zero rules broken and zero drawdown. ​4. Refusal of Human Identity Verification ​To resolve any automated false positive flags caused by standard dynamic mobile IPs, I explicitly offered to undergo: ​Live video identity verification (holding official ID) ​Screen-share verification of trading terminals ​Complete ID re-verification ​Blue Guardian explicitly refused, hiding behind automated template replies stating "internal parameters cannot be disclosed or questioned." ​I demand the full release of $1,470 USD ($1,040 + $430) plus initial account purchase refunds. Trade with this firm at extreme caution.

I purchased a 50k instant account After trading for 2months and finally was qualifying for a payout that is when my payouts was rejected and the reason was device sharing and try reaching out them through their website so they block me from accessing their website.

I strongly warn against Blue Guardian. After passing my evaluation and earning a $785 profit, they banned my account (#440702) and confiscated my earnings, citing a 'Shared Device' violation. I provided undeniable proof that this is a second-hand device used 3 months after the previous owner, with zero overlapping or simultaneous trading. Shockingly, their compliance team admitted there was no activity overlap, yet they still enforced a predatory policy to steal my hard-earned profits. They are not a legitimate firm; they operate by manufacturing excuses to deny payouts. Do not waste your time or capital with this company.

I am writing this to alert the trading community about the business practices of Blue Guardian I experienced during my recent payout request from a funded account. I successfully traded a $100k account to $112,621.58, maintaining full compliance with all written rules, including Daily Drawdown, Maximum Drawdown, and Trading Days. My performance included high-conviction discretionary shorts on XAGUSD from the ~115 level on Jan 30, all executed while respecting the firm's drawdown parameters. The Issue: Upon requesting a $9,000 payout ($7,650 net), Blue Guardian initiated a "compliance interview." During this call, I was asked to complete a risk-management exercise for lot-size calculations on the spot. Because I stumbled on these calculations and typically manage my risk differently - through a set-dollar amount - and despite my trade logs proving all trade executions were within the governing rules and restrictions, Blue Guardian proceeded to deny my payout citing a "Hard Breach." Unscrupulously, they also instantly blocked my login access to my Dashboard, but luckily I took screenshots of everything beforehand. Why this is Bad Faith: Non-Contractual Breach: Nowhere in the Blue Guardian Customer Agreement is a "failed interview exercise" defined as a Hard Breach. Subjective Denial: The firm is using a subjective interview to avoid paying out a large profit. Refusal to Justify: The firm has now ignored my formal appeals sent by multiple emails and support tickets opened in their Discord - it has been over 1 week that I've waited for a response, repeatedly being assured in their discord that "the team will reach out to you shortly", but nothing ever happens. If Blue Guardian is a legitimate firm that respects its own Terms of Service, they will reinstate my account and process the payout I have earned through skill and discipline. As a final word of caution to the trading community, I would encourage anybody considering this firm to spend some time in the "general chat" on their Discord server. You may notice that the moderators are quick to delete messages expressing legitimate concerns and frustrations from traders in a similar situation as myself.

Doesn't matter how good the support team, platform, or spreads are if the company shaves you. They declined my payout without any evidences. As a result, denied a payout of around $5k and closed the funded account. Didn't buy any challenges with them anymore.

Denied a $6117.45 payout while accusing me of 3rd party trading, shared an excel file with random account IDs and told me of copy trading. I was trading only 1 account with BG across this whole time.